Reader Question – The book about the guy that was flirting with her but then she finds out he’s dating her sister!

Antoinette is looking for this one! Ooooh I’ve heard of this one before. In fact, it makes me think of The Bronze Horseman but you’re not mentioning historical so I’m assuming it’s not. Either way, it sounds like it will make me FUME just right!!!

She asks:

Hi,

I was wondering if you could help!

Not really sure how long ago it was, maybe two years ago.

In one part I remember that the male was either seeing or had a fling with this girl and then he ends up at her parents house and he’s either dating or engaged to her sister. Think it happens when he walks into the house and the sister introduced him to her.

Hopefully that helps.

Cheers

I have a feeling there are quite a few that have this little kick-to-the-gut in ’em. 😉 So let’s make a list!!

Any guesses?

Sherida: 👀 sounds like my kind book!!

CorkDork: Is it YAish? Without Merit: A Novel by Colleen Hoover maybe?

Kayla: Sounds like Without Merit by CoHo

Pia: It could be Without Merit by Colleen Hoover

Jill: Hmm Giana darling?

Andrea: my guess is The Affair (The Evolution Of Sin Book 1) by Giana Darling!

Madalina: Could it be The Affair- The evolution of sin by Gianna Darling ?

Penny: One Night Stand by JS Cooper & Helen Cooper

Ashley: Heat Wave by Karina Halle???

Sofia: Definitely sounds like The Bronze Horseman!

Jenny: My guess is The Bronze Horseman

Ambraneve: Hate to Love You BY ELISE ALDEN?

Kelly: Degradation (The Kane Series Book 1) by Stylo Fantome

Sherry: Ok There was a book where he was a construction worker and was working on the house next door and he likes the younger sister but ends up dating the older sister that was a b*%ch.. I can’t remember the name of it 🤦🏻‍♀️

Maryse: SHERRY!!! Yeah!! I dunno if this is the same one you’re thinking of, but if it’s this one… Something in the Way (Something in the Way Series Book 1) yes!! It could very well be!!! 😀 !!!

Kat: Following I wanna know this one

Antoinette: really appreciate the help with this book. So far it’s not the one I was looking for 😩

Maryse: Awww!! Well, we’ve got quite the list for this trope, so far, and we’ll keep looking and adding to it until we find it. 😀

Kristina: This sounds like “In the Rough (Diamond Girls Book 3)” (previously titled Emeralds) by K.A. Linde

Melanie: The Secret (The Evolution Of Sin Book 2) by Giana Darling?

3764Tracey: Is it Heaven’s Sinners (The MC Sinners Series Book 2) by Bella Jewel? Spike and Ciara are friends but when he comes one day to get her, her sister introduces herself to Spike.

Neepa: It could be Wrong Girl by Lauren Crossley.

Ambraneve: Only with You (The Best Mistake Book 1) by lauren layne?

➔➔➔  Browse more reader questions (solved & unsolved) here. 😀 Maybe you’ll find a solved one to read or have a guess for us for one that’s still unsolved.

Have a reader question for us to solve? Send it to me here.